Summer of Supergirl Special #1

CRITIC REVIEWS Back to Top

• 10

  ComicBook.com - David Harth

  Jun 24, 2026

  Last year, DC did a fantastic job of putting out Superman comics that a movie fan could read and fall in love with and Summer of Supergirl Special #1 shows how good they’ve gotten at that. This comic is perfect for someone who just walked out of the movie and it will get them into the main book. Honestly, the way this issue slots into her ongoing series, forming the perfect jumping on point for it, is something I’ve wanted to see from a movie tie-in comics for years now. This is how you make movie fans into comic fans. It’s a comic that lays out exactly who Supergirl is and gives readers the kind of adventures they’re in store for if they stick around. The art and writing are top-notch, from a group of creators who some of the best at what they do, a showcase for new fans. Read Full Review

• 10

  Nerd Initiative - Megan Nichole

  Jun 24, 2026

  Summer of Supergirl Special #1 was a beautiful homage made in honor of one of the most iconic characters in DC history. The writers and the artists brought so much depth to the pages of the comic. This is an absolute must have for your week’s pull lists! Read Full Review

• 10

  Super Hero Hype - Matt Morrison

  Jun 24, 2026

  Summer of Supergirl Special #1 does everything a movie tie-in comic should. Beyond exploring Kara Zor-El’s character in the comics compared to the movie, it also showcases why she deserved a solo DCU film. This is a must-read comic for all Supergirl fans, old and new. Read Full Review

• 10

  Supergirl Comic Box Commentary - Anj

  Jun 26, 2026

  Look, the Waid story is an A++++ story. The others are solid. The art throughout the book is gorgeous. This was a true special. Read Full Review

• 10

  Impulse Gamer - Howard Smith

  Jun 29, 2026

  Summer of Supergirl Special #1 consists of a fun and significant appreciation for Supergirl. Jam-packed with stories befitting fans of Supergirl and for those that are just getting into the character, this is a must-read for the summer. Overall, the comic book is a great read and a perfect release at the time of the Supergirl film. Be sure to check out this comic book at your local comic book store or online, where you can purchase your copies. Read Full Review

• 9.0

  Geek Dad - Ray Goldfield

  Jun 24, 2026

  This story is just as fun and chaotic as the main series, with some great art and a surprisingly sympathetic take on Lobo (even if his daughter disagrees). Read Full Review

• 9.0

  COMICON - Scott Redmond

  Jul 08, 2026

  It’s Kara Zor-El’s world and we’re just living in it as the mighty Kryptonian takes another spotlight with ‘Summer Of Supergirl Special’ #1. A trio of stories highlights the many facets of this character and her impact not only in the DC Universe but far beyond as well. Read Full Review

• 8.8

  Fanlight Zone - Ken M.

  Jun 24, 2026

  The Maiden of Might starts off the summer with a enjoyable trek into her legacy as a hero. Each creative team showcases a new side to Supergirl while reminding the audience she is not like her cousin. The art teams craft distinct looks at events while maintain a heroic vibe throughout. A welcomed addition into the ever-growing legacy of the Woman of Tomorrow. Read Full Review

• 8.5

  AIPT - David Brooke

  Jun 24, 2026

  Summer of Supergirl Special #1 succeeds as both a celebration of the character and a reminder of why she remains one of DC's most compelling heroes. Each creative team approaches Kara from a different angle, whether through lighthearted cosmic chaos, heartfelt friendship, or a reflection on her long and often complicated history. The result is an anthology that captures her strength, kindness, and determination without losing sight of the challenges that have shaped her. While some stories resonate more strongly than others, the collection as a whole leaves little doubt that Supergirl deserves the spotlight currently shining on her. It's an enjoyable and welcoming tribute that longtime fans and newcomers alike can appreciate. Read Full Review

• 8.5

  Comic Watch - Jamison Nilsson

  Jun 25, 2026

  At 48 pages, the “Summer of Supergirl Special #1“ is an enjoyable though predictable read, well dedicated to Supergirl, that acknowledges her importance without simply watering her down to “Superman’s cousin.” Further, the individual art teams each nail different variations of the cartoonish aesthetic that a set of stories like these thrive on. The stories themselves don’t connect, but they don’t need to, as each one focuses on a different part of the Woman of Tomorrow’s character. Beyond the heart and the optimism of the three stories, there is little nuance due to a lack of an overarching storyline so the trade-off for the reader is in the variety of the different stories and how their creative teams go about them. Read Full Review

• 8.4

  Graphic Policy - Logan Dalton

  Jun 28, 2026

  The story is a recontextualizing of 60+ years of sometimes insane stories into a sales pitch for why Supergirl is awesome and should have her own movie and comic. And the Crisis on Infinite Earths and Woman of Tomorrow callbacks are pure beauty. Read Full Review

• 8.0

  Comic Book Clique - Frank Jarome

  Jun 25, 2026

  The Summer of Supergirl Special #1 is a very fun read, with three stories that all have one thing in common: showing us what a great character Kara Zor-El is, and hopefully enticing us to check out her ongoing series. It certainly did its job with me, and I will be picking up the current story arc to check it out. With creators like these working on her, the character is in very good hands indeed. Read Full Review